This book is troubling for a variety of reasons. Full of creative ideas for quickie uses of literature to entertain children during their “library time,” it continues the stereotype that teacher librarians are babysitters, even though the author sees the activities as ones that can be integrated into full collaborative learning activities. For our taste, this is the type of book that library paraprofessionals or volunteer parents could conduct in the library. The concentration is on an activity itself for itself. And, while it could be tied to something being taught in the classroom on that same topic, we don’t find enough substance in critical thinking, reading strategies, or curricular integration to warrant use of the ideas by the professional teacher librarian trying to move into the center of the curriculum. However, the support staff could be using these activities to engage children who are not participating in collaborative units being done in other parts of the library at the same time. Not recommended for the teacher librarian.
This series of books about favorite teen authors is for both librarians, teachers, and teens who really want to know their favorite author in depth. The volumes are full of biographical articles, reflections of the authors, essays about their most popular titles. They would be particularly useful to aspiring young authors who need reassurance that writing can be even more than just a hobby. Both are just plain good reads. David Loertscher
If the Best Books for Young Adults list is available on line each year from YALSA, then why compile a combined list from 2000-2006? The answer is that the collection is much much more than just a complilation of the lists. The book begins with a thorough analysis of YALSA’s efforts over the years to create lists of the best. The chapter that analyzes the trends in publishing for young adults is simply the best analysis we have seen. It looks at trends such as the feminization of teen literature, changes in family life as represented in the books, trends in the growth of graphic novels and many other aspects of publishing. We are then treated to combined lists across the seven published lists of themes not used in the lists published each year. These theme lists include: friendship, humor, love and romance, science fiction, among others followed by a number of nonfiction themes. After this section, the collective lists are arranged by author complete with annotations with additional indexes of various types. For any person working with teens, whether librarian or teacher or counselor, this book is a must have and a must read reference. The YALSA best books list is selected by adults, it is true, rather than a list popular with teens, but it represents one view into the world of YA literature worth considering. Highly recommended.
If you as a teacher librarian think it is difficult to get into the classroom to collaborate, then read this book about the role of the reading coach. Yes, they are supposed to collaborate and coteach. Yes, they have difficulties. It is fascinating to read another perspective on this problem and ther theire recommendations for solutions. Read and find out that teacher librarians, reading coaches, and by inference, any other specialist in the school has lots in common. Do we as teacher librarians explore the commonalities? Are we in competition for attention with other specialists? When we really collaborate with classroom teachers, are two heads really better than one? This book is worth acquiring and requiring both the reading coaches and the teacher librarian to read it. Perhaps reading two titles such as Behond Bird Units by Loertscher, Koechlin, and Zwaan would be instructive for both professionals. Certainly the question comes around to: how could we as specialists combine our efforts and unlock that classroom door to the miracle of collaborative education rather than isolated frustration. It is an idea worth investigating and thus, this is a great title to start exploring the possibilities. Highly recommended.
Sandra Cuban and Larry Cuban
(Teachers College Press an The American Library Association, 2007, 150 p. $_____. ISBN: 978-0-8077-4795-7)
With two major authors and with the stamp of approval of two major publishers, one expects to find important and major proposals for a new generation of literacy initiatives. Sadly, such is not the case here. The authors castigate the state of technology in the public schools including one to one computing as largely a failure and turn to experiments in the public library where hosts of computers and wireless are available as a major component in bringing literacy to those who do not have access to computing in our society. One cannot deny this success and in every public library we have visited recently, the computers are usually busy and serve those who do not have access. However, the authors rarely acknowledge the existence of school libraries. Instead, they discuss schools in general. They spotlight a number of public library computer literacy programs. They spotlight no school library literacy initiatives. It is unfortunate. And for this reason, pass this title by.
Page Information
|
Wiki Information |
Recent PBwiki Blog Posts |